Actaully the best test 'review' is to go to an off roading event and see what everyone else is running on mostly stock DD rigs. I think mainly you will see BFG and goodyear, the GY's are probably 'leftovers' from when they bought it or owners replacing them with what was on it when they got it. Like my S-10, it came with wranglers so thats what I kept buying for it, they lasted 50K and I was happy more or less but that was before I really knew there there big differences in AT's...
I've had GY's, Pirelli's, Dunlops and finally bfg's on my 98. They all had their pros and cons, the GY's were terrible on wet roads, the pirelli scorpions were awesome when sears sold them for $70 a tire, not so awsome when they stopped and local pirelli dealers wanted $140... Dunlops rover AT's were OK but were only so-so on wet roads. The BFG AT/KO's are proving to be a good all round tire, wet roads a bit better than the Dunlops, pretty good in snow, very good off road. Sams club and BJ Wholesale carry them at very good prices compared to say Sears when they are on sale. One TJ owner I was talking to the other nite bought a set of 31 BFG AT/KO's at a local big name big tire shop, paid $170 a tire out the door, big difference compared to the same tire at BJ's for $127... or $480 at Sams club for a set of 4 in a package.
As for buying tires over the net, why, shipping and handling then finding a local shop to do the mounting and balancing plus old tire disposal will kill any savings gained over the net not to mention any 'warranty' involved. Unless you have a tirerack in the neighborhood. I had a nail in one of my sidewalls, took the jeep to BJ's where I bought them and was in and out with a new tire in 30 minutes, still under warranty after 30K, did not cost me a dime except for gas to drive 30 min to get there.
About the only tires I would buy over the net would be some kind of speciality tires that the dealers don't normally carry but even then I'd price them locally first just to check. Shipping now a days is a killer. I bought Warn bumpers for our TJ's, quadratec wanted around $200 + tax[~$12] + shipping [~$30], got them locally for $199 + tax and no shipping, local warehouse had them in stock to it pays to shop and take a catalog with you so you you can show them that they may be charging outrageous prices...be an educated consumer...its your money and better the odd $80 or so in your pocket than someone elses..