Well, to all of those who offered their insight and help with this issue, I am happy to say I finally got it figured out. It was the intake manifold gasket. I didn't even originally think to look at that, but after picking the brains of some Jeep-only mechanics at my local five-star Chrysler/Jeep dealer, we figured it out. I hope this helps all the people who said the had the same problem, and hopefully this will become a good refrence to all that stumble across it in the future on this post.
Thanks again! Bill
Thanks again! Bill