I wasn't gonna comment ........at first.
And yes it's going to look good to you it's your Jeep. That happens, deal with it.
I'm not sure what you have for tools but you can do very good and quality work with minimal tools. You just need a lot more patience. And a lot more detailed planning.
I build a 4 link longarm suspension using only a sawzall, chop saw, hand drill, mig welder and a grinder.
By planning on what your going to build using cardboard templates, you can buy the metal in the correct width and thickness to avoid alot of unnecessary cutting.
When you started the bumper how much thought was put into it? did you look at other bumpers? was your main concern mounting the winch or using whatever you could find? Does you approach angle mean anything to the type of wheeling you do? How is it braced into the unibody? where you trying to make a boat anchor or a bumper?
None of these questions should cause you alot of thought, if you planned it out.
Like i said, not having the tools is no excuse, just take your time.
Dingo