We've got a string of nice weather here so I am tackling some things. First on the list was to repair the drivers side upper hinge.
Long story long: the drivers door never really closed right, and I could see a sliver of daylight and feel a breeze through the A-pillar. I thought this was just an alignment problem so I ignored it, but when I did the body work I discovered that the upper door hinge had been repaired, and the installers had welded the hinge in such a way that the upper door would no longer seal against the body. I asked my parents about it and mom said she was taking pops to the airport and the door fell off, they held it in place with bungee straps long enough to get him on the plane then took it to the dealer for repairs.
Here is the repair. Basically the dealer riveted and glued a piece of heavy sheet metal over the A-pillar and then welded the hinge back into position. It's a comprehensive repair--the hinge is on there good and solid--but it was done poorly
The specific problem is that the hinge was reattached to the body with a large gap and at a 90 degree angle. However the upper hinge on the passenger side is 87 degrees, and putting the drivers side hinge at 90 degrees causes the top of the door to point outwards. So by putting the hinge where they did the top of the door would never close. This pic shows the problem using the A-pillar as the reference; the hinge ends up pointing up and outwards
I removed the hinge to get a better feel for the situation. As you can see there is plenty of good metal there.
I was planning to use
WrenchMonkey's fix for this but after studying on the problem for a bit I decided to just make a straightforward repair. I did find some good tips in his thread though, such as using a long piece of threaded rod to hold the hinge in the correct proximity
Rewelded with the right angle and position, painted, and sealed with silicon.
I have done some preliminary fitment tests and without adjusting the hinges the door is much closer to the body. I still need to get the door aligned but I have no worries about it.
Interestingly, while I was examining the passenger door for comparison purposes I noticed that the upper weld was starting to crack, and the lower weld was almost nonexistent
So I beefed both of them up, painted, and resealed that hinge too
The passenger door does not sag anymore now
About 4-5 hours total time I guess, half of which was getting everything set up and then cleaned up