i can say outta expierence that the 8.25 isn't the best axle, especially if you have the rubber fill plug. the one in my jeep now got about 2qts of water in it while washing it.......also, its got 160,000 on it and i've had to replace the pinion bearings where the plug leaks and the previous owner didn't understand the roaring. also, i've test drove a few jeeps recently lookin for my next xj, and have found 3 bad 8.25's in these jeeps....the 44 is stronger and more parts availability.....just my thoughts...no one jump my gun...