Thanks for all the Replies so far!
So, here's what I've some up with. I should have mentioned in my first thread I do not plan on using/adding a tire carrier (probably go roof rack mount) The other thing is I'd like one that sticks out just a little bit so I can stand on to reach the roof rack!
Bulletproof Mfg.
Good looking bumper, sounds extremly tough. Diamond plate rear quarter panels available. (not sure if I want diamond plate, would prefer smooth finish) One of the more expensive bumpers I've found. Looks like it will stick out a bit. With D-rings and tabs. $675
Tomken
Another decent looking bumper with the features I want. Bolt-on steel bumper endcaps that appear to extend up 'past' the fender to the tire. Appears to stick out enough. But no D-rings and tabs $510.00
Nate's 4x4
I understand this is a great bumper, from what everyone here is saying. Tabs built in. Probably extra cost for a receiver built in? Don't know if it will stick out far enough for me Worth the wait I've heard, but 1-2 months? Can he extend the side panels? Or can I buy them elsewhere that will work? Priced right < $250.
Detours
Slim-Line SLS is what I'm looking at here. Receiver hitch built in, tabs, sticks out far enough. Wraps around to fender but not quite far enough (goes to the factory fender, not all the way to the tire) Could this be customized? $450 with receiver.
Rock Lizard
No XJ rear bumpers on the website, sent them an e-mail. Looking forward to response.
Hanson Ent.
Same as Rock Lizard. Website lists an XJ rear bumper coming soon.
Custom 4x4 Fabrication
Looks like a decent bumper. Welded on endcaps and bolt on rear rocker guards. Tabs and D-rings can be added. Appears to have receiver beneath bumper (but could be hidden hitch?) $430 with rings and tabs.
C-Rok
Probably a good bumper, but similar to Nate's in that I don't know if it will stick out far enough for me. I like how it wraps the rear quater panel, but I could do without the C-rok. Also, not sure I like the mount system. Is this bumper rectangular tubing?
$480 with tabs
JCR Offroad
Stage 2 bumper with tabs and d-rings. May not stick out far enough. The big thing here is that it doesn't wrap the rear quater panels, but again, I could probably get those somwhere else, right? $250
Well, those are the ones I've obviously researched via the internet (no phone calls were made). In writing this 'research' I've realized that if the bumper doesn't stick out far enough to stand on to access my roof rack, then just stand on the tire. That would probably work just fine!
Let me know what you all think, any feedback would be great (I appreciate all of your responses already) Also, pictures of your rear bumper never hurts. The biggest issue I'm 'stuck' on is the rear quater panels coming to the tire.
KodiakXJ
wow, pretty big thread, but I bet it helps a couple other people than just me!