1bolt said:
What is too slick and how does it adversely effect an engine? Come on guys I know you all are smarter than that... Sure don't use it for break in because it will take longer to seat the rings, but after that there's no such thing as too slick. and the only good reason not to use a real synthetic oil is economic or purely practical (like your driving conditions warrent very short oil change intervals)
If the oil manages to impair tappet rotation or valve rotation, it's "too slick" and will cause trouble.
The bad rep synthetics get ("Synthetic causes leaks!") is usually from the fact that it manages to clean the sludge off of a partially failed seal, and that sludge had been helping the seal hold oil in. No sludge? No seal.
Granted, pretty much
all spark-ignition engines should be run-in on 30-wt "non-detergent" oil, and I'll run a new engine on dead dinosaurs for the first 20-30Kmiles or so (to get the rings seated well. Moly barrel-faced rings take rather longer than cast iron...) But, switching to synthetic after that should not pose any trouble - and I've not run across valvegear rotation failures as a result of synthetic oil so far.
How do tappets rotate in an engine? Check the surface - it ain't flat. It's got a slight "crown" - a circle with a
radius of five to ten feet. The cam lobe itself has a very slight taper to it - if you look carefully at a well-used cam, you can see a slight "polished" band just off-centre of the lobe, and the tappet foot will have a polished spot on it to match.
Why do tappets rotate? Similar reason to the odd gear ratios in axles - to keep presenting fresh contact surfaces, and to reduce/decelerate parts wear.
This is also why you can't use a "flat tappet" cam with roller tappets - roller tappet camshafts
are not tapered, since the tappet doesn't rotate (the tappets are also tied together in pairs.) Using the tapered cam with a roller tappet will result in wearing through the roller foot of the tappet - just like a roller tappet cam will fail almost immediately with flat tappets (from one of two possible causes - either the ramp is too steep, or the tappet won't rotate in the bore.)