Ives - replied in your other thread. I'm honestly not sure (never had a new AW4 to break in), but I'd probably end up doing what you described, then changing the fluid a few thousand miles later to flush out any metallic debris leftover from finish machining + breakin.
Ryder - for your '91? You could unplug the TCU entirely and it won't really even notice, the '97 and earlier are pretty dumb and the '96 and earlier are REALLY dumb. Even if you do get a CEL on a 91 it'll go away as soon as you disconnect and reconnect the battery.
With the shifter in 1-2 you want power to S1 for 1st and power to S1 and S2 for 2nd. I doubt powering or not powering S1 with the shifter in 1-2 will make a difference though as it selects the 1-2 gear pair vs the 3-OD gear pair (i.e. S1 being off = you are going to end up in 3 or OD) which is forced hydraulically by the manual shift valve with the shifter in 1-2.
Basically, solenoid 1 selects between the 1-2 pair and the 3-OD pair while solenoid 2 selects 1 or 2 from the 1-2 pair, and 3 or OD in the 3-OD pair.
Tech nerd sidetrack:
From the shift table you may also note another interesting feature - it's set up so that only one solenoid drive value changes from each gear to the next, which allows for more controlled shifting. For instance if this was not the case, here's an example:
Assume:
first S1 off S2 off
second S1 off S2 on
third S1 on S2 off
OD S1 on S2 on
Note: this is NOT how the AW4 is set up - anyone who's reading this for info on the AW4, don't get confused!
See that both solenoids flip values from second to third...
Now imagine that the solenoids are a bit sticky and you go to shift from second to third right at the redline in second. Three things could happen:
* solenoid 1 is stickier than solenoid 2, and turns on a little slower, while solenoid 2 turns off immediately. So for a second, you have S1 off and S2 off and the transmission blips into 1st when you were already at redline in second. NOT GOOD!
* solenoid 2 is stickier than solenoid 1, and turns off a little slower, while solenoid 1 turns on immediately. So for a second, you have S1 on and S2 on and the transmission blips into OD before going into third like it was supposed to. Clutches slip more than they have to, the engine slows down then speeds up again, things get worn, you don't accelerate as much as you wanted to. Not going to blow anything up, but not ideal.
* the solenoids switch at exactly the same speed and you go smoothly into 3rd.
The setup with only one solenoid changing state at a time is used for this reason - it's impossible to have those kinds of flaky issues, all that changes is you change gears a bit slower if the solenoids get sticky. It's known as "gray codes" and is frequently used for sensors and actuators for this reason.