I would choose whichever is in better condition. I own a 1990 XJ, last year of the Renix 4.0 and a 2001 XJ. At RPMs below 2000, the Renix has more torque. Over 2,000 rpm, the late-model engine has more go. It all depends on what you want, and the condition of what you can find to buy. My Renix...