Go to non perfromance Header?

Got a 95 with a header cracked badly at the collector. ALso getting awful gas mileage (about 11 to 12 MPG combined so I'm also trying to combat that). What's the go to option for an affordable header now days? I see a bunch of 80ish dollar options on EBAY, 100-150 options though Quadratec/Crown ect. And of course the 400+ dollar performance options.

(Cross posted to Cherokee Talk Forums)