Sorry for posting in your chapter, but protection knows no boundaries.
I like my front skid. I have a 3.5" RE lift and 31" tires, and use a JCR Offroad front bumper. The skid gives the front a finished look and a place to hang my JKS sway bar end links when disconnected.
I believe the skid benefits are different for lift size and model year. I have heard the earlier skids (or was that aftermarket???) can contact your steering linkage after hard hits. If that is the case, I would not run one either.
I don't think I follow that logic on my '99, but then again I don't expect to severely contact a rock on the trail that fast, either. I have tested the skid on some hairy conditions and have not had a problem yet. Yeah, that is the dilemma; it would be too late at that point.
A taller lift = more aggressive trail conditions = higher risk of impact.
A smaller lift = a need for more protection = closer to the ground = higher risk of impact.
:dunno: You got me, man. I dunno which is better, but I like the look.