xj151 said:
if the 8.8 swap was just a straight bolt in like the 44 which would be a better choice.
It's gonna depend on you to decide what swap makes more sense. Cost is usually the biggest determiner of which to swap under your rig.
The XJ D44 usually runs a premium price. For me, local price was about $400-450 from a yard and most private parties. If you are patient and look, you can also find them for as cheap as $100. They are also not as plentiful as a 8.8 or other D44s. They are Drum brake equipped.
Isuzu D44 and Honda D44s have funky carriers, but you can find them factory geared with 4.56. These axles are 6 lug 6 on 5.5" (I think 5.5" anyway) and use a pinion flange. You can usually find a D44 1310 Yoke on the cheap though. The 6 lug is kinda a PITA to convert unless you plan on swapping in a Waggy D44 front. Disc brake equipped for the most part (mid 90s up are).
MJ D44 is a SUA, so the perches will need to be converted, but the yoke is 1310, so one less thing to wory about. These also tend to be harder to find, but not as hard to locate as a XJ D44. Drum brake equipped.
Ford Explorer 8.8 rears are pretty easy to find. The 95+ are disc brake equipped. The 8.8 is a tad narrower, but only by about 1.5". As mentione din the thread, they are not a bolt on swap in the sinse it will bolt up without a conversion. These rears can be had fairly cheap sinse there are so many of them. If I were doing a 8.8, I would locate a cheap disc equipped Explorer rear. Put it in the garage and start to throw cash at it when I could. TnT UBEs, Superior Super88 kit, a truss, and gears. That combo will make for a STRONG rear axle that is a hair WIDER (thanks to the S88 kit) than stock.