if its a surco, it has a mounting kit that mounts to the factory roof rack side rails. You could get a Surco that is narrower than the gutter mounts, just make sure the cross bar supports on the bottom of the rack are as wide as the Jeep so you can gutter mount it. My buddy mounted a Surco that was narrower than the Jeep and just had the crossbars sticking outta the side of the rack.
My Garvin Wilderness mounted to the gutter mounts and the rack was the same width as the Jeep (from gutter mount to gutter mount), but it was a heavy mother and was kinda overkill for carrying only a spare and some lights