• Welcome to the new NAXJA Forum! If your password does not work, please use "Forgot your password?" link on the log-in page. Please feel free to reach out to [email protected] if we can provide any assistance.

Got XJ stuck on test drive minor damages.. how should I handle this? + clutch problem

90Pioneer

NAXJA Forum User
Location
USA
My finacee is currently driving a shitbox Geo Metro, so I have been looking to get her into a safer, more reliable rig.

I found an ad in the local paper for an 89 Cherokee. Last night they brought it over so we could take a look at it.

It's a 1989 Cherokee, Inline 6, manual AX15 transmission, 4x4 w/ vac disconnect front axel, manual windows/locks, new O2 sensor and new muffler. It has a 2" block in the rear and 2" coil spacer in the front, sporting 31" Toyo ATs with 60% tread. The paint is very faded, and 159k miles. Also has idiot gauges. AC works and blows cold, recently serviced. Clutch supposedly replaced 1.5 years ago. No service records of any kind. Owner was asking $2,000.

After inspecting this jeep in my garage, I noticed it needed a few things. The coolant was very brown, and the breather tube on the front of the head was broken off. Also the rear hatch shocks were not working, and a few other minor things.

I asked to drive the vehicle, and the owner tossed me the keys and said have at it, and did not express interest in coming with me. So I went out for a couple miles and drove on the highway. The motor is quiet, ran smooth, and had plenty of power. The transmission shifted smoothly, was crisp, and didn’t appear to have any problems. I did not check the clutch fluid when inspecting the vehicle.

On the way back home I decided I would try out the four wheel drive, and ensure everything was working properly. I drove back past my house and into an empty dirt lot, covered with grass and lots of tumble weeds. I have walked through this area before and didn’t see anything big, just tumble weeds and grass.

Well I drive into the lot and engage 4 high. Works fine. Keep in mind it's pretty dark out, and cloudy. I go a little further, and engage 4 low. I decide to drive it back towards the road, but I have to go over this big tumbleweed. Well when I drive into the tumbleweed, apparently it was concealing a large rock. I hear a bang and a scrape. So I stopped immediately and looked under the jeep, it wasn’t my rig so I didn't want to damage anything.

Turns out I drove the driver side control arm onto a rock. Now this isn’t my rig, and I didn't want to potentially damage anything by driving it off the rock, which would have been very doable. So I jogged back to my garage and drove the owner back out to the lot in my jeep.

I explained what happened and asked him to drive it off the rock. Well, I don't know what to say about him other than he just made the situation a lot worse, and basically moved the rock against his front diff, leaving both front and rear tires without traction, after the wheel spin. In hindsight I should have driven it off the rock myself, but it's too late now.

At this point we decided it would be best for me to pull his jeep from the rear with a tow strap. And we did so. I pulled him in reverse and freed his jeep completely. BUT while he was reversing back to the street, he somehow ended up running over another rock all together. I watched as he attempted to "rock" the jeep out, and what he ended up doing was scraping the undercarriage of the jeep on this second rock. He was rallying it pretty good, rolling the rock with him as he went forward and backwards. Eventually he worked it to the side and was able to turn, and pivot around the new rock. I had suggested we just move the second rock, but the owner decided against it. It would have been easy to slide it from out under his jeep.

So the jeep is finally freed and we drive it back to my garage and inspect it for damages. Both the owner and I crawl under to look at the jeep, and we both agree there is no damage, other than some light scraping on the front diff, control arm, and unibody. All is well.

My finacee and I tell the owner that we are going to sleep on it, and we'll call him with our decision the next afternoon. Fast forward to the next day (today), and like I stated the previous day, I called him with our decision. My fiancee and I agreed we should offer $1400 for this jeep, which is the Kelly Blue Book private party value. The owner tells me he has someone else interested who wants to look at it, and he'll think about it and get back to me. He mentions nothing about the condition of the jeep, or any problems.

Several hours later he calls me and says my fiancee and I should come over to his house and discuss my offer. We agree and go over there a few hours later, after I got off work.

When we arrive, little did we know, we were in for a surprise. The owner tells us there is much more damage to the jeep, supposedly caused by last night adventure. He tells me that one of the rear shocks is really scraped up, and the muffler is dented. I look under the jeep and verify this is true, the shock has a scrape that took off the white paint, and the muffler has a couple small dents in it. He implied this was my fault. Although he was the one who caused the damage while driving the jeep out, I do accept responsibility for putting him in that situation and have no problem with paying for him to get a new shock and muffler, if we decide not to buy the jeep.

BUT here's where it gets good. He lives about 9 miles from my house, while driving the jeep home last night, he claims it was driving great until he got about 1/4 mile from his house, and the clutch went to the floor, and would not shift.

I immediately checked for clutch fluid, which were was none. We filled it up and the clutch began working just fine. We test drove it for about 3 miles. The owner pointed my attention to two lines going into the AX15 transmission. I crawled under there and looked. On the driver side of the trans, there are two places which it looks like a hardline connects to. One of the ends didn’t have anything connected to it. I am unfamiliar with the AX15, so I am assuming the line with no hose connected to it, is possibly a breather tube, only with no rubber line running up to the engine bay. Is this correct?

The other hardline right next to it, I traced, it was hard, then went to rubber, and up to the master cylinder/clutch area in the engine bay. I noticed there was fluid leaking from this line. It went into this rubber gasket thing on the transmission. I was able to move it several inches in and out of the trans. I do not know if this is normal or not. I did notice that it appeared to have been slightly leaking for some time. It did not appear as if a bunch of fluid had suddenly poured out.

Like I said, after we added more fluid to the clutch reservoir, it started working fine again. I do not know what the problem is, and was hoping someone here could point me in the right direction as to why the reservoir lost all its fluid. Does the line need to be replaced? What are the two lines, that goes into the rubber gasket thing, coming off the AX15 for?

The owner was implying that whatever went wrong with the clutch was also my fault. I will accept responsibility for the shock and muffler, but I do not think the clutch failing was caused by me. I believe it was just a coincidence. We do not even know exactly what is wrong, which is why I'm posting here. I hope that someone can help me out.

The owner and I agreed to take the jeep to a mechanic tomorrow, see what he says, and we'll go from there.

Help me out guys. What's wrong with this jeep, and do you think I caused whatever is making the clutch not work properly? Oh I also checked and there was no fluid running into the fuse box.
 
Last edited:
Re: Got XJ stuck on test drive minor damages.. how should I handle this? + clutch problem

Um, where's the proof you test drove? "What Jeep? Who are you? Why are you harrassing me and my wife?"
 
Blaine B. said:
Um, where's the proof you test drove? "What Jeep? Who are you? Why are you harrassing me and my wife?"

I'm going to do the right thing and not screw the guy. I'll accept responsibility for things I caused, but I don't think I had anything to do with the clutch problem.
 
Re: Got XJ stuck on test drive minor damages.. how should I handle this? + clutch problem

Well just buy the Jeep then, and you won't have to deal with him.

How can you fubar a clutch on a rock anyway?

Maybe it's a problem he knew of prior and is just trying to blame away....
 
Blaine B. said:
Well just buy the Jeep then, and you won't have to deal with him.

How can you fubar a clutch on a rock anyway?

Maybe it's a problem he knew of prior and is just trying to blame away....

I offered him $1400 as is with clutch problem, but he says he wants $1600.
 
Re: Got XJ stuck on test drive minor damages.. how should I handle this? + clutch problem

Man pay the 1600. You shouldnt have gone wheelin on a test drive. What if that was your XJ some yahoo got stuck. Just eat the 200 bucks man.
:looser:
 
Re: Got XJ stuck on test drive minor damages.. how should I handle this? + clutch problem

Any 4x I've ever owned or helped others buy I've verified that the hi and lo range worked. I'd pay him to replace the muffler and shock, get a receipt that he signs before you hand him the money and walk away. You can bet there's more wrong with that jeep than he's letting on, there always is. If he wants more tell him to pound sand.
Cherokid
 
Re: Got XJ stuck on test drive minor damages.. how should I handle this? + clutch problem

From what you describe, it sound like a normal internal slave set up. The second line is to bleed the system and does not go anywhere. If the leak is on top like you say, it's no big deal. Get new parts and bleed the system. If it's in the slave, you have to pull the transmission.

Unless you pulled the line loose in the lot, this was not caused by you. It just chose to run out of fuild at that time. If you are worried about doing the right thing and you are only $200 apart, pay the man the $1,600 and fix it yourself.

Oh and ditch the blocks in the rear if you buy it.
 
Re: Got XJ stuck on test drive minor damages.. how should I handle this? + clutch problem

my guess is he's put "normal" fluid in there before and if you look down on the floor below the clutch master you'll see where fluid has been seeping out. i had fluid seeping from mine till i read about using castrolGT fluid or girling. girling designed the unit and those are the fluids that work without losing fluid. it's an older jeep, you did not cause the clutch problem. shocks, mufflers and undercarriage are SUPPOSED to be scraped up on a jeep.
 
Re: Got XJ stuck on test drive minor damages.. how should I handle this? + clutch problem

metalgearxj said:
my guess is he's put "normal" fluid in there before and if you look down on the floor below the clutch master you'll see where fluid has been seeping out. i had fluid seeping from mine till i read about using castrolGT fluid or girling. girling designed the unit and those are the fluids that work without losing fluid. it's an older jeep, you did not cause the clutch problem. shocks, mufflers and undercarriage are SUPPOSED to be scraped up on a jeep.

Yes it was a lapse of judgement to go into an unknown area on a test drive

I'd also support the idea of the $1500 counter offer. You were both there, compromise seems fair.

X2 on the above recommendation for Girling or Castrol LMA fluid. This is all I ever used in mine and I've had no problems with 2 different internal slave Jeeps. An XJ I drove for 2 years and a YJ I've been driving for 11 years. The XJ had ATF in the master cyclinder when I brought it home :-O I sucked the ATF out with a turkey baster, filled it with Castrol LMA and flushed the snot out of it (repeatedly bleeding it) I ran that clutch master for 2 years without trouble until I sold it.

I wouldn't freak out about the clutch cylinder, fill the cylinder with good fluid, bleed it well, should be OK for a while.

If it has leaked brake fluid down through the fuse panel, you may want to look for issues there as well
 
Re: Got XJ stuck on test drive minor damages.. how should I handle this? + clutch problem

There is almost no way to tell or know that you caused the clutch slave cylinder to go bad unless the line was yanked.. It could have gone out just by driving it on the street and.... And That problem could have been there for a long time and he may not even known about it.. I say don't pay for it or pay more for the Jeep because of it.

As far as the shock and muffler goes, that's your call. If it was just a scratch in the shock and it's not dented, it doesn't call for a new shock, maybe just some touch up paint.. For the muffler, it all depends how big the dents are.

Also, can you tell if the scratches and dents are new?? Just like you said, you let him drive it out and he could have caused the problems himself..


So, I think that the shock and muffler replacement is a maybe and the clutch issue is definitely a "NO GO"...

My $.05
Elias
Eh-lee-us
 
Re: Got XJ stuck on test drive minor damages.. how should I handle this? + clutch problem

He could have got home and slightly open the clutch bleed screw, to create a problem!! he can smell your moneyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy mate...........give him the f@*king elbow!!!
 
EliasJ123 said:
There is almost no way to tell or know that you caused the clutch slave cylinder to go bad unless the line was yanked.. It could have gone out just by driving it on the street and.... And That problem could have been there for a long time and he may not even known about it.. I say don't pay for it or pay more for the Jeep because of it.

As far as the shock and muffler goes, that's your call. If it was just a scratch in the shock and it's not dented, it doesn't call for a new shock, maybe just some touch up paint.. For the muffler, it all depends how big the dents are.

Also, can you tell if the scratches and dents are new?? Just like you said, you let him drive it out and he could have caused the problems himself..


So, I think that the shock and muffler replacement is a maybe and the clutch issue is definitely a "NO GO"...

My $.05
Elias
Eh-lee-us


He did cause the problems when he drove it out. I sat and watched as he rallying the jeep back and fourth on a rock. The original stuck, was when I just scraped the driver side control arm onto a rock. A turn of the wheel would have given the tire traction against the rock, and it could have been reversed out pretty easily. BUT I was the one who put him in that situation which is why I fee somewhat responsible. Report from the mechanic to come later this afternoon.
 
Re: Got XJ stuck on test drive minor damages.. how should I handle this? + clutch problem

GermanXJ said:
Man pay the 1600. You shouldnt have gone wheelin on a test drive. What if that was your XJ some yahoo got stuck. Just eat the 200 bucks man.
:looser:

He really didn't, sounded like it was just grass or whatever, some sort of tumbleweed hiding a rock......
 
Re: Got XJ stuck on test drive minor damages.. how should I handle this? + clutch problem

Cherokid said:
Any 4x I've ever owned or helped others buy I've verified that the hi and lo range worked. I'd pay him to replace the muffler and shock, get a receipt that he signs before you hand him the money and walk away. You can bet there's more wrong with that jeep than he's letting on, there always is. If he wants more tell him to pound sand.
Cherokid


X2.. I would keep looking for a different Jeep

I think it is noble of you to accept the shock and muffler damage, but honestly, if the are only cosmetic, I would not worry about it.
 
when the man threw you the keys and said "have at it" that was his first mistake.

it seems like he is pretty straightforward though, so i wouldnt try to screw him. tell him you will give him $1400 for the jeep and thats it.

if he doesnt take it, walk away. you owe him nothing. $1400 is more than fair for a 18 year old cherokee in decent shape. the clutch either has a bad master cylinder or most likely a bad hydraulic line. the pre-90 cherokees can use a brake line as the clutch line.... aka its a $5 fix.

you should have unstuck it yourself btw
 
Re: Got XJ stuck on test drive minor damages.. how should I handle this? + clutch problem

True, if you unstuck it without any damage there'd be nothing to tell anybody.
 
Re: Got XJ stuck on test drive minor damages.. how should I handle this? + clutch problem

Think of it this way. Most people will say that any vehicle that will drive under its own power will be worth $1000.
I'd probly buy it and part it out if you don't drive it. you'll get your money's worth out of it either way. My wife and I looked high and low for 4 and a half months for a CHEAP daily for her. Finally found a 98 XJ Limited for $5500 only 10 minutes away. Lifted and on 32s!
You'll find one at a great price eventually.
 
Re: Got XJ stuck on test drive minor damages.. how should I handle this? + clutch problem

I would say just buy the jeep for $1500. By the time this guy sucks you dry for every little nick and dent you DIDNT see in the middle of the night, you'd probably just could have bought the Jeep originally.
 
Back
Top