I don't know about the shocks in question, but many shocks are designed to resist rebound more firmly than compression (jounce). This makes for a less jittery ride while still maintaining control. Make sure when you test it that you first run it up and down a couple of times to get the bubbles out. Then compress it steadily. It should not change resistance as you compress. If it starts easy and gets firmer, or otherwise varies, it's not good. If it's a gas filled shock, observe how it expands. It should expand slowly, and at a constant speed, and come out all the way. If it suddenly speeds up like a screen door closer, it's bad. If it's not gas filled, you will need to pull it, but the same rule applies. It should resist evenly.