lazarus said:
my god, I have changed at least four different pumps and have in every case been able to use that old nasty pipe you guys mentioned. In every case they were all in great shape too. all i had to do is put a litte heat on it at the base , hold the water pump with a monkey wrench , and crank the damn things out! putting them back in was just as easy. I do like the job and write up 5-90 did on his brass/copper plumbing stuff(cannot remember which) but i think that maybe here in indiana corosion may be a greater problem with soft metals like that versus the steel of the old one?
I know what you mean - I grew up in Lafayette.
The nice thing about brass is that, being softer, it is somewhat more resistant to corrosion. That's why boat-builders and shipwrights use so much of the stuff - because it's harder to corrode. CRES can also work, but it's rather spendier and harder to work.
Just remember that there are brass fittings that spend all of their lives going INTO and OUT OF saltwater (which is murderously corrosive on steel, especially when hot!) and they last 20-30 years or more.
And, the nipples you need are cheap enough to just automatically replace them when you change the water pump (every 10-12 years,) so that makes it a non-issue.
By the by - when you get it at the hardware store, the "pipe" (threaded stuff) is usually C360 brass, and the "tube" (sweat soldered stuff) is #2 copper plumbing alloy. Both can co-exist neatly in a system - I've got brass pipe nipples off the water pump, and #2 copper plumbing replacing the heater lines (because I got tired of trying to track down - and pay for! - those moulded right-angle heater hoses...)
No worries about using brass - it will last longer than steel, hands down. There is no sound
engineering reason for using steel in plumbing - but the accountants get involved, because steel costs less than brass. See what happens when we let accountants and/or lawyers get involved in engineering decisions?
5-90