calvynandhobbs said:
I have an 89 Pioneer and it has the D35 non c-clip with a metal screw in fill plug. I have a trac-loc in mine running 33s and have not had a problem with it at all. I've been told that the early D35s without C-clips are stronger than the later c-clip style. I do keep an extra pair of axles shafts in the XJ when I'm wheelin down at the Badlands or anywhere else that I will be on rocks.
It's not so much that the shafts are stronger - I think they're actually the same size. The issue comes when you "drop a C" for whatever reason (shaft gets pushed in, button breaks off, ...) and your wheel decides to go along without you.
C-clip and retainer plate axles are both of the "semi-floating" type, but the retention differs. C-clip axles are retained at the inside extremity of the shaft, and it's not a "positive" retention. "Retainer plate" axles are retained just behind the hub flange with a plate that's bolted onto the housing flange, and the bearing is actually pressed on (with a retainer collar pressed on behind that.) Upside - if you snap a shaft in the middle, you're going to keep your wheel with you.
The C-clip "innovation" (yeah, right,) can be found on a number of axles, and you can also get "C-clip eliminator kits" for many of them. You'll find a few for the Ford 8.8", if you feel like finding out what I'm talking about. (The Ford 8.8" is a common swap, but you should get that kit if you're going to do it.) The C-clip Dana 35's didn't show up on the XJ until after 1990, so you should be fine.
The D35 will handle up to a 31" tyre, unless you get stupid with the skinny pedal. You can also tow with it moderately - I didn't have any trouble taking a 3,000# box from ATL to SJC, and it can do more if you're careful. If you expect to spend some time 'crawling, I'd definitely suggest an upgrade - but for mud, sand, dirt - unless you're dragging, you should be just fine for a while.
As I said before, you should have the D35. It should have the retainer plates (if you look in when you're changing oil/inspecting your differential, you can see if there are C-clips by checking the side gears.)
A retainer plate shaft is also easier to change on the trail, since you don't have to actually open up the differential. Just lift the side you're changing a few inches, pull the plate, swap the shaft, and put it back down. You just need to tilt the housing away from where you're working to keep all the oil in there.
Also, if a C-clip shaft gets pitted at the bearing surface, replacement is
mandatory (the bearing rollers ride directly on the shaft surface.) You can get away with a little on the retainer plate shaft - you just need to be able to press the bearing on and off to change it.