lawsoncl said:
Except lots of folks, inlcuing myself, have noticed lower idle oil pressures after running a Fram filter for a few months. It also takes forever for the pressure to come up on cold starts. I'm not sure why, but running a Napa silver doesn't do this.
This can occur, but it's typically not attributed to the filter. More likely oil shearing in our meat grinder timing chains with oils that have undue amount of VII (common 5w-30/10w-40 oils).
The long waits for oil pressure can be due to the junk Fram anti drainback valve having your oil filter empty. There's also an "inertia" effect if you're using something like a 15w-40 (or any heavy weight oil). That oil mass just doesn't want to accelerate on a dime. The oil pump will "spin its tires" in relief ..sorta like a burn out until the tires hook up ..or maybe an old steam locomotive where the wheels spin a bit as the mass of the train starts moving. So, it applies its max pressure ..but the fluid flow "is what it is" until the flows reach unity. At this time (when the filter and its downstream galleries are empty OR when you're in relief) is when you'll see substantial (as in measurable) pressure differential across your filter. With the relief closed, and assuming you don't have radical internal pump leakage (I've never seen it) ..then you've got a "flow dicated" series fluid circuit from the view of the filter. The engine is BY FAR the biggest resistance that the oil flow will see. Being "in line" the filter, however you perceive it to be "restrictive" ..MUST fall into a hierarchy of "relative resistance". That is, it will always be in "proportiion" to the total pressure produced. Now this minor resistance can be elevated, slightly, via loading ..but still is very small.
The big filter test on BITOG had some flaws in it. The test used a standard applied pressure and measured the downstream pressure result. If they (BOB) had set a standard downstream pressure, assuring that the test engine was receiving an identical flow (same pressure into a static restriction), then you could have read the elevations that the filters added upstream. Many of the readings were in excess of bypass valve settings, which implied that the oil pump relief was open.
Oil flow is like a bumper to bumper traffic jam. All the roads are always full ..every exit has cars in line. The only difference, normally, is the energy required to move the traffic at a given rate. This we call "pressure". It is, in most views, "back pressure". Back pressure from all the oil playing bumper cars on the way back to the sump. This back pressure will vary with viscosity ..but it won't alter the way that the backpressure is developed.