I second the Truxus as a good compromise.
A lot of people knock pro-comp tires....while I've never had a set personally, a wheeling buddy has a set of their 33MTs and they do well. He beats on them pretty good and hasn't had any problems with them.
If you're on a budget, pretty much any budget MT should do you pretty well. I've had great luck with a set of Mastercraft MTs. They flex well when aired down, and the sidewalls seem to be nice and tough. Also, they ride on the road real well once aired up.
Another good budget MT is the Mud King. They're pretty cheap, and they're actually an XT. Looks wise, they look like a cross between an MT and a TSL, but since it says XT on the sidewall, you can get road hazard warranty on them, which is a bonus for a lot of people.
If it isn't something that you have to commute in also, then go with a TSL or LTB!!