Going spring over puts more force on the springs as you accelorate or just apply throttle. It allows extra leverage that the leafs need to soalk up. This problem is exasorbated by the fact that comanche owners do this to their already worn out, sagging springs.
There is a correct way to do a SOA. Use new or known good leafs. Use longer, "anti" wrap perches and new U bolts. Then possibly add a torque bar to inhibit axle rotation.
To my way of thinking, I am getting 5.5" of lift with a spring UNDER. I have no axle wrap issues or additional perches to buy. I relocated my lower shock mounts to the axle tube. My only difference in clearance, is the springs are hanging under the axle. Maybe two inches, I could have done a Ubolt flip and gained (lost) another inch. But to me this is a non issue. I have skidders under there.
I am glad to hear you have no spring wrap issues.
good luck,
CW