I have ran most varieties of "great" off road tires in the past 10 yrs, but have not tried any of the overly expensive newer super tires though (IE:Krawler, Creepy, ect.)
on the same built very well TJ I ran over time sets of;
*BFG muds - great mileage tire for what it is, would never buy again due to weak sidewals and not very good over all compared to others below
*TSL Thornbirds - OK NEVER BUY THESE I was very nieve and those only lasted about 250miles before I had interco exchange them for
*Boggers - best all around tire off road I ever owned, but flat spotted badly and drove horribly. but for off road (any kind really but technical rock crawling) they were the best I ever owned
*TSL Radials - one of my favorite tires. Very strong and wore well, great on rock, never had in snow, and mud was good. Heavy I though though for a radial.
*BAJA CLAWS radial variety. Buddy exact same setup as mine but on MTR's would go everwhere I did and vise versa. Clawdrove as well as the TSL radials to me, wore kinda fast though (liek 17,000 miles) but locked front and back with a heavy foot. Very tough tire that in sand would prevail over teh MT/R by far. Otherwise alot like the
* Goodyear MT/R - I HATE goodyears, always have always will, all except this tire. FOr the price at the time they were a great buy for a 35". These worn the best of all my tires up there but the BFG. They were great in rock and ok in sand. Could have been better in mud but I got over teh mud thing quickly, not my gig I found.
Now I am going on to either Pit Bull Rockers, or TrXus MT. If I had to pick one tire from up there for 25% on road and 75% off road, it would be a Claw, or maybe TSL Radial. But I like trying new things so it will probabily be a rocker. just my opinion.