What I'm saying is that the flat gasket diddn't work well on my 96, factory valve cover. The surface underneath is slanted and seems to push the gasket around, doesn't seal right- even with sealer and I'm pretty good with gaskets.
I tried the flat gasket because- it was $7 instead of $25 (with my employee discount) and I wanted to get the cast aluminum cover at a junkyard, my painted stamped one is scratched. I did not find a useable cover that day so decided just to replace the gasket and spraypaint the cover. I wound up tearing it down again to put the composite gasket on.
However- the composite gasket seats using the head bolts (or studs, don't remember) but these have pins in them to align the holes in the steel gasket, I don't think earlier heads have this.
I don't know if aftermarket stamped ones or ones used on other Jeep models have a flat mating surface or not. Also, the 96 motor has different CCV fittings than before so you will have to re-do that if you want to adapt a later stamped cover.
Oh, my CCV elbows are specified for a 97 I believe, Wrangler. They stick up farther than the old ones and punched a hole in the hood liner fabric (but I later took that thing off). It was all the dealership had in stock.
My recommendation is if you change valve covers to use a later model (HO) cover, but the cast aluminum one avaliable in pre-95 models. Which was what I wanted to install anyway!