HUSKY vs. X-TREME CATCH ALL

[Drewman]

I'm looking at getting some rubberized liners for the carpet in the XJ. I've come across two major brands, Husky Floorliners & Xtreme Catch All.

Which one does a better job?

If you don't have a bias one way or the other why do you like the ones you do have?

Up front, No, pulling up the carpet and rubberizing the floor pan is not a option.

Thanks.:)

[Planetcat]

I've had husky liners in 4 vehicles, including my XJ. Floor mats and cargo liner. I have small kids who thrash my vehicles and the husky's are nearly bullet proof. They're strong, nice looking, pliable, and I can't wear them out - even on driver's side where my heel digs in from the gas pedal. The only negative (my wife's opinion, not mine) is that they look a little industrial with the diamond stamp pattern. I think it looks awesome. I've had the tan, black, and the grey (XJ) and they match interiors well. The grey and tan get scuffed easily because the colors are light. I deliberately put a black cargo liner in my XJ grey interior so it didn't look too scuffed up with abuse. Sorry to sound like such an advertisement, but I really like them.

[Wa Woody]

I second the Husky. Great when it's messy. Easy to clean and they stay in place.

Woody

[CaptTrev]

I have em. they're great.

look good, work well, easy to clean, and tough

ive got em in black...and i think the diamond plate looks awesome

[wek91xj]

love my HUSKYS

[prljeep]

I also have to go Husky-

I had a set in two Explorers. They hold about a gallon of melted snow or at least an extra large Taco Bell drink. I wish I could find a set to fit my MJ!

PRLJEEP

[jallen]

i've got to vote the other way...catchalls. they are a bit "spiffier" than huskys (in my opinion) and they do a great job at grabbing the garbage and cover everything.

[ylojelo]

I got the xtremes as well and really like them. By pictures, I think the huskys my fit the front pass floor a bit better, but not enough to bother anyone. I didnt like the shiny plastic diamond plate, the matte pebble finish is much nicer (IMHO)

[LRRH]

i've got the husky. it the winter they hold about an average of an inch of salt water from settling into my carpet and rusting my floorboards. I love them.

[thompson97]

i'm about to purchase some liners to get ready for the upcoming winter (i work at a ski resort). do you guys have some pics that we could use to compare the two? other than the manufacturer/seller pics from the internet. thanks.

[LRRH]

http://lrrh462.homestead.com/files/husky1.JPG

http://lrrh462.homestead.com/files/husky2.JPG

http://lrrh462.homestead.com/files/husky3.JPG

[Drewman]

Thanks for all the opinions,
I think I will be going with the Huskys,
and best of all, my in-laws are buying them for my wife and I for Christmas.

[8Mud]

Something to keep in mind. They not only keep much of the moisture and dirt out of the carpet/padding, they keep what ever does get under there, from evaporating. Cancerious looking spots seem to form faster under, rubber. Have to take the carpets up (at least a corner) once in a while, for a look see.
In the winter, when evaporation is minimal. I periodically lay an open newspaper under the rubberized matts, to suck up as much moisture as possible. No matter what I do, the first hot days of spring, make whatever moisture is trapped under the rubber, to start smelling like sour owl excretment.