well that makes a world of differance. shine on the gears is normal. pitting? well thats whats going to make noise. sounds like you have figured out your problem. how you got the junk yard to foot the bill for new bearings is a much bigger story though. REALLY? well if you planned a gear ratio change, then now is the time because they will have to re-set the ring and pinion when installing new bearings anyhow. and goatman is correct. ring and pinion clearance hardly never changes much in normal use. but thats not to say they were setincorrectly by someone in the first place. its allways a good idea to check the tracking anyhow.